To Be or To Do? Navigating Career Crossroads

Miami-Dade firefighters respond to house fire
Photo: Miami-Dade Fire PIO

In today’s fast-paced, achievement-oriented society, many of us find ourselves caught in a relentless pursuit of success. As firefighters, we climb the promotional ladder, seeking out opportunities for advancement, and chasing titles, accolades, and recognition, often at the expense of our true passions and purpose. But what if the key to fulfillment lies not in what we are, but in what we do?

This article challenges the conventional wisdom of career success, urging us to reconsider our priorities and motivations. It posits a stark choice. Will we focus on building our personal brand and climbing the promotional ladder, or will we dedicate ourselves to making a meaningful impact on the world around us? The former, which I term the “to be” mentality, can lead to a sense of accomplishment, but it may also leave a void when we realize that external validation doesn’t equate to lasting fulfillment.

This article will explore the implications of choosing one path over the other, examining the true meaning of success and fulfillment, contrasting the allure of status and power with the rewards of purpose-driven work.

The Illusion of Success

Our society is deeply ingrained with a culture that equates success with status, money, and power. We are bombarded with images of glamorous lifestyles and aspirational careers, creating an illusion that fulfillment can be achieved through external validation. The relentless pursuit of “to be” somebody often comes at the expense of our true potential and purpose.

This “to be” mentality is what has us chasing titles, promotions, money, and awards—the shiny objects that distract us from what truly matters. We become so focused on climbing the corporate ladder that we neglect to consider the impact of our work on others or on the community we serve. This preoccupation with external validation can lead to a sense of emptiness and dissatisfaction, even as we achieve our career goals.

A particularly insidious concept discussed is “failing upward,” a phenomenon where individuals are promoted despite poor performance or incompetence. This highlights the perverse incentives often present in organizations, where appearances can be more important than substance. By rewarding those who excel at self-promotion over those who deliver results, organizations inadvertently reinforce a culture that prioritizes image over impact.

The Importance of Purpose

True fulfillment comes not from external validation but from a deep-seated sense of purpose. It challenges us to question our motivations and to consider the long-term impact of our career choices. The emphasis shifts from appearing impressive to making an impact.

It’s essential to align our work with our values and passions. When we find meaning and purpose in our careers, we are more likely to experience job satisfaction, increased engagement, and a greater sense of fulfillment. We must reflect on our motives and identify what truly drives us.

By prioritizing purpose over personal gain, we not only enrich our own lives but also contribute positively to our organization and the community we serve. When our work is aligned with our values, we are more likely to make meaningful decisions with true purpose and to act with integrity. By focusing on using our skills and talents to solve problems, create value, and contribute to something larger than ourselves, we can find a deeper sense of purpose and satisfaction. This “to do” mentality emphasizes action, contribution, and growth. Ultimately, a purpose-driven approach to our careers can lead to a more meaningful and rewarding professional life.

The Cost of Ambition

The “to be” path, the relentless pursuit of personal gain and advancement, can come at a significant cost. There can be unforeseen implications if we prioritize individual success over the collective good. In our quest to climb the promotional ladder, we may be tempted to compromise our values, to prioritize short-term gains over long-term team success, and to neglect the impact of our actions on others.

Authenticity and integrity are extremely important. By choosing to prioritize personal ambition over purpose, we risk alienating colleagues, damaging relationships, and ultimately undermining our own values and credibility. True success is not measured solely by external achievements, your title, position, or rank, but also by the quality of your character and the positive impact we have on those around us and the community as a whole.

It’s important to note that choosing the “to do” path requires courage and resilience. It means challenging the status quo, pushing boundaries, and potentially facing resistance from those who prefer the safety of the familiar and those who do what everyone else is doing. Those in positions of power and authority may view such individuals as threats, as their ideas and actions can disrupt the existing order. It’s essential to recognize that making a real difference often involves taking risks and being prepared to face opposition.

Finding Your Path

We must strive to align our career paths with the principles and virtues that govern our choices. We must embark on a journey of self-discovery, to identify our core values and explore our passions and interests while also allowing us to contribute to something larger than ourselves. By understanding what truly matters, we can make more informed decisions about our career paths.

Ultimately, the choice between “to be” or “to do” is a personal one. We must empower ourselves to make conscious choices about our careers and prioritize purpose, fulfillment, and impact over external validation. By embracing a mindset focused on contribution and service, we can create a more meaningful and fulfilling professional life.

Self-reflection is crucial in this process. Take time to consider your strengths, weaknesses, and aspirations. What are you naturally good at? What kind of work brings you joy? What truly drives you? What kind of legacy do you want to leave behind? By gaining a deeper understanding of yourself, you can make more informed decisions about your career path. Building strong relationships is also essential. Seek out mentors, colleagues, and friends who support your goals and provide guidance. A strong support network can help you stay focused, overcome challenges, and find new opportunities.

*

The choice between “to be” or “to do” is a pivotal one that can shape the trajectory of our careers and lives. While society often views climbing the corporate ladder as success, true success, fulfillment, and lasting impact come from aligning our work with the values, principles, passions, and virtues that govern us.

By prioritizing purpose over personal gain, we not only enrich our own lives but also contribute positively to the world around us. It is essential to break free from the illusion of success and to focus on building a career that is both meaningful and sustainable.

Ultimately, the decision is in our hands. As the adage goes, “A person is a product of what they work on in life, not of what they were in life.” The choices we make about our careers and our lives are interconnected. What we choose to do with our time and how we earn our money shapes who we become. It’s about deciding whether we want to “be” something or “do” something that truly matters. The earlier we ask ourselves these questions, the sooner we can align our actions with our values and build a fulfilling life.

Ironically, choosing the “to do” path may mean forgoing promotions or titles. However, the long-term benefits are substantial. Building a career on a foundation of purpose and impact creates a solid platform for enduring fulfillment and success. While promotions and titles may follow later in your career, they will be earned through proven merit rather than merely occupying a position. Essentially, your accomplishments will define your rank, not the other way around.

Remember, it’s not about the title you hold, but the difference you make. To accomplish great things and protect our people, we must sometimes take great risks and have the courage to face possible consequences. By embracing a “to do” mentality, you can create a career that is both personally rewarding and impactful.

Jairo Rodriguez is a 33-year veteran of the fire service and a lieutenant with Miami-Dade (FL) Fire Rescue (MDFR). He has developed the department’s heavy rescue rotator training program, the department’s “MDFR Gear Lab,” and several other training programs. He has been deployed to various major catastrophes nationally and internationally with FEMA’s FLTF-1 Urban Search and Rescue Team. He is a FEMA Structural Collapse instructor and has instructed in firefighting, technical rescue, marine/shipboard firefighting, and leadership programs internationally. He is certified as a paramedic, marine/shipboard firefighter, rescue SCUBA Diver, technical rescue technician, and holds a bachelor’s degree in emergency management.

Blake Stinnett and Charlie Brown

Next Rung: Navigating Trauma and Building Support Systems

Hosts Blake Stinnett and Charlie Brown candidly discuss the profound impact of trauma in the fire service.
Twin Falls (ID) Chief Retires

Twin Falls (ID) Fire Chief Retires After 7 Years

At the end, Les Kenworthy received the traditional “final call” from a dispatcher, and after the crowd enjoyed refreshments, was given a ride home in…